kosmo - See all 471 of my articles
Leave the First Comment

This will likely become a mini-series … statistics are great, but can be abused.

Today’s focus is on the “transitive” property of statistics. My example will be an issue that many people are well aware of. The issue is important and is a problematic societal issue. I am definitely not suggesting that the problem doesn’t exist – but I am suggesting that the arguments have at times been twisted to say things that the number don’t necessarily support.

Fact 1: Members of group A are paid less than members Group B for the same work
Fact 2: Members of group A, on average, have salaries that are 50% of those of members of group B

thus, the creation of
“fact” 3
Members of group A on average make, on average, 50% of members of group B, for the same work.

The only problem with this is that this is overly simplistic. You cannot blend the first two facts. Too many other variables exist.

Let’s illustrate:

Group A, 100 people
6 brain surgeons @ 135,000 = 810,000
94 engineers @ 45,000 = 4,230,000
Total = 5,040,000

Group B, 100 people
50 brain surgeons @ 150,000 = 7,500,000
50 engineers @ 50,000 = 2,500,000
Total = 10M

Let’s test facts 1 and 2

Fact 1: Are members of group A paid less than members of group B for the same work? Yes. They make 10% less.
Fact 2: Are members of group A, on average, paid ~50% of the salary of members of group B? Yes. 50.4%

But when we come to “fact” 3:
Members of group A on average make, on average, 50% of members of group B, for the same work.

This is not true. Members of group A make 90% of what members of group B make for the same work.

Keep an eye open and you’ll see occasional use of the “transitive” property by otherwise reputable sources. Why? Either because the person doesn’t know any better, or because it’s easier than delving deeper to find the “split” statistics – and 90% of people aren’t going to see the problem. The key point here – when you read the news, you should not only scrutinize the facts for accuracy, but also the logic used to piece the story together. The best statistics in the world cannot undo the harm of illogical thinking.

End note: With this particular example, there is the issue of why members of group A tend to have less than members of group B. Is this due to personal preference, lifestyle choices, or a lack of opportunity. This is a good topic for discussion, but it is beyond the point of this article – that people need to analyze the statistics more closely.

Kosmo is the founder of The Soap Boxers and writes on a variety of topics, including the Fiction Friday original short stories. You can purchase some of Kosmo's work at the company store. Like Kosmo's writing? You can leave a tip.

Like this site? Subscribe via RSS, Subscribe via Email, or Follow us on Twitter.

You might also like these other articles from The Soap Boxers (auto generated)

• A memory like no other Staff writer and golf fanatic Johnny Goodman (not his real name) shares his experience at the 2009 Masters. This year I...
• World Baseball Classic Update Pool 1Game 1: (Sunday) Japan vs. CubaJapan beat Cuba 6-0 behind the arm of Daisuke Matsuzaka. Matsuzaka threw 61 of...
• Who was Ponzi? In the wake of the Madoff and Stanford scams, "Ponzi Scheme" is a term that gets thrown around a lot.  A...

Related articles from other sites (auto generated, not affiliated with The Soap Boxers)

• Trumpington Vicar to be Sacked I've commented a number of times about the ongoing difficulties in Trumpington - we now have the results of the...
• Why do I need Life Insurance? Happymoneyshopper.com has the answers... FAMILY LIFE INSURANCE // Research shows the average cost of raising a family is estimated to be over£200’000, so imagine how...
• How I Review My Annual Social Security Statement I receive my annual Social Security Statement like clockwork each fall.  The contents of the statement, particularly the estimate of my retirement...

•  
•  
•  
•  
•  

Comments

Leave a Reply

Set up a customized icon to appear next to your comments!

Is your comment not appearing? Don't worry - I'm not censoring you. Your comment just got caught in my spam filter. It will be viewable shortly (almost always within 24 hours, and much more quickly 90% of the time).

Name

Email Address

Website

Comments

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail

---

Writers for The Soap Boxers are freelance writers who work as independent contractors. Opinions expressed by the writers may not necessarily reflect the opinion of management.

Copyright for all content belongs to the writer identified in the byline. Copyright for any content not associated with a particular writer belongs to Kosmo. Copyright for comments belongs to the writer of the comment.

Content from The Soap Boxers cannot be reused in any manner other than what is allowed under the fair use doctrine of US copyright law or the applicable copyright laws of your country.

© 2008-2010. All rights reserved.

Please email Kosmo at Kosmo@ObservingCasually.com with any questions you may have.

The Soap Boxers is a division of Hyrax Publications

The Soap Boxers is hosted by Dreamhost. Sign up by clicking on the ad below and get your first year's service for just $36 - $3 per month!