$68 Property Taxes – The JoAnn Watson Saga
kosmo - See all 468 of my articles
2 Comments
Welcome, visitors from Atom! Don’t be a stranger – please explore The Soap Boxers when you are finished reading this article.
A reporter recently discovered the fact that Detroit city council member JoAnn Watson had been paying just $68 in annual property taxes for about a decade. Her home was incorrectly classified as a vacant lot by the city, when in fact there had been a house on that property since 1926.
Watson said that she noticed the change in taxes, but believed it was due to the fact that a tornado had hit the house. Let’s digest a few points of the story.
Did she know?
If Watson had escrowed her taxes (as many people do) , then it would be somewhat believable that she simple wasn’t aware of the amount of property taxes she was paying. Although I can probably guess my property taxes to within $50, I suspect that a lot of people don’t pay a lot of attention to what individual amounts make up their escrow payments. Watson did not escrow her taxes, though, so she would have been very aware of the amount, since she would be physically writing a check for the taxes. Watson does freely admit that she was aware of the amount of her taxes.
I find it a bit strange that her tax accountant wouldn’t have pointed out a disparity when comparing her mortgage interest deduction to her property tax deduction – but perhaps she did her own taxes.
The tornado
The tornado is a fascinating aspect of the story. Watson says the the tornado did great damage to the home, specifically to the roof and foundation. She felt that this damage caused her home’s assessment to be lowered. A few question about the tornado remain unanswered:
- Watson says that the tornado occurred in either 1993 or 2002. I have never suffered a direct hit from a tornado, but I have come frightening close. I sincerely doubt that I’ll ever forget that the tornado that passed about a block from my house before ripping through another part of town was in 2006. It made enough of a lasting impact that I doubt I’ll err by nine years on an estimate.
- Watson also says that she never informed the city (assessor), nor did she file an insurance claim. Why on earth would you NOT file a claim? I understand the logic of not filing small claims for fear of higher premiums. However, a tornado directly hitting your house is a near worst case scenario – it’s the reason why you would buy insurance in the first place. If you aren’t going to file a claim in such a situation, why ever bother to have the insurance?
Mortgage
Watson obtained a mortgage in 2002 (after the tornado, apparently) for $60,000. It never dawned on her that the fact the the appraisal was high enough to warrant the loan was an indication that it had regained value (for reference, she paid $40,000 for the home in 1990). Watson says that she thought that appraisers used their “financial wizardry” to help her get the loan. That’s a great quote, because I wasn’t aware of the fact that appraisers used financial wizardry, nor did I realize that it is their job to try to get you a mortgage. I thought they were simply trying to estimate the fair market value of the house.
The future
First of all, Watson should probably stay away from neighborhood barbeques. The neighbors are not happy that they were paying roughly 40 times what she paid in taxes. I suspect that her time on the city council (along with the $80,000 salary and use of a car) is also coming to an end. Watson has informed the city of the error and is prepared to pay back taxes that are owed on the property.
You can read more about this in the Detroit Free Press.
Kosmo is the founder of The Soap Boxers and writes on a variety of topics, including the Fiction Friday original short stories. You can purchase some of Kosmo's work at the company store. Like Kosmo's writing? You can leave a tip. Like this site? Subscribe via RSS, Subscribe via Email, or Follow us on Twitter.- Crime and Punishment: Weather Balloons and Quarterbacks Edition The Heene Hoax On Thursday, much of the country was transfixed on a weather balloon floating across the Colorado sky....
- Dealing With Elderly Parents (Part 2) Several weeks ago, I published an article about dealing with aging parents. In that article, I discussed treating parents with...
- I Know That I Can't Take It No More ... It Ain't No Lie Bye, Bye, Bayh. No, itâs not the NâSync song Iâm talking about. Itâs Evan Bayh, the rarely buzzed about Senator...
- Why Is Interest Tax Deductible? Did you know if you were a company and borrowed money that the interest you pay is a tax write-off?...
- 10 Things I Have Learned From Working At Home. A lot of people have emailed me over the last 7 months about my working at home. Just so everyone...
- Happy New Year (and personal finance links) I know it's a little late, but I'd like to wish you a Happy New Year. You may have noticed...
Comments
2 Responses to “$68 Property Taxes – The JoAnn Watson Saga”
Leave a Reply
Set up a customized icon to appear next to your comments! Is your comment not appearing? Don't worry - I'm not censoring you. Your comment just got caught in my spam filter. It will be viewable shortly (almost always within 24 hours, and much more quickly 90% of the time).Copyright for all content belongs to the writer identified in the byline. Copyright for any content not associated with a particular writer belongs to Kosmo. Copyright for comments belongs to the writer of the comment.
Content from The Soap Boxers cannot be reused in any manner other than what is allowed under the fair use doctrine of US copyright law or the applicable copyright laws of your country.
© 2008-2010. All rights reserved.
Please email Kosmo at Kosmo@ObservingCasually.com with any questions you may have.
The Soap Boxers is a division of Hyrax Publications
Soap Boxer Search
Just For Laughs
Category
Recent Posts
Search by Writer
Lazy Man and Money
Blogs Written By Us
Financial Blogs
Fun Blogs
May 27th, 2009 @ 7:00 am
A friend of mine just emailed me one of your articles from a while back. I read that one a few more. Really enjoy your blog. Thanks
Total Comment by Mike Harmon: 1
September 16th, 2009 @ 10:18 am
[...] think to challenge the finding despite living in a fully functional house. This meant she was paying $68 in property tax annually, about 40 times less than her [...]